Fatigue Design and Evaluation Committee 

                     

FD&E Home

Search   

Events Calendar   

Short Courses

Minutes, Presentations, Agendas

Information 

ATV Project

Weld Project

Bolt Project

Divisions

Data Online

Links

Publications

Steering Commitee   

 

To All Members of SAE F.D.& E.
Here is a proposal for a new FD&E research project. If you are interested and want a piece of it, talk to Raj Thakkar, or others on the committee. ... or, just go do it. Have fun too.

Objective:

To develop new correlated software that will allow engineers to measure the durability of components of proposed vehicles by means of a "digital prototype" simulation.

General Plan:

Select an inexpensive, simple, existing vehicle that can be easily modeled with respect to vehicle dynamics and component stress-strain behavior. Create a computer model of the vehicle and "drive" it over a digital proving ground route. Test the actual vehicle on the real course and measure the component loads, test the component durability, and then compare the digital predictions with the test results. Assess where models need to be improved and fix the deficient theory. After good correlation has been achieved, try changing some components, through light weight material substitutions or material processing changes, and then re-test and re-analyse for prove-out of the digital prototype procedure.

Detailed Plans:

  1. Select "mule" vehicle: A $3500. 4x4 ATV vehicle has been selected for purchase. The U.of Toledo has agreed to act as the home base site for vehicle storage/teardown/build, subject to funding from SAE FD&E members. Presumably some senior student design projects could also be "spun-off" from the overall project.
    If any other university would like to get involved heavily, and needs a vehicle or parts - apply to SAE FD&E (thakkar.raj(at)towerautomotive.com )
  2. Digitze Vehicle Geometry points. Using a 3D spatial geometric digitizer, determine the positions of all the connection points between all significant components. Ford has volunteered to try this with vehicle no. 1.
  3. Measure Components Inertial Properties: after digitization, or possibly by using vehicle No.2, tear down all components and determine their weights, center of gravities, (moments of inertia?), and possibly some spring rates, bushing rates(?), shock damping characteristics.
  4. Create Vehicle Model using ADAMS/DADS: using the geometry & properties of the components, build the rigid body model. Check the model with some simple geometry test track events.
  5. Create Loads Vehicle: Using strain gages and other transducers, create a loads measurement vehicle. Sufficient channels should be selected to allow both the mearsurement of vehicle simulation inputs, and also the correlation channels that are needed for subsequent evaluation of the simulation. This is a non-trivial exercise. Advice from experienced test people and vehicle modellers is critical. Mike Messman, Art Page, Dan Morrow, Ric Mousseau, MTS, ...
  6. Measure the significant modes (e.g., bending and torsion modes below 50 Hz) of vibration with experimental modal analysis of the ATV, with and without the suspension. Spectral analysis of the experimental component load time history can determine if the modes play a significant role in the dynamic response. The modal information can serve both to correlate the vehicle dynamics model and to assemble a flexible body dynamics, if needed. Possibly can be done by Brian Dabell & co at E.G.G.
  7. Measure Vehicle Loads: Record the time traces (min. 1000s/s/chan) as the vehicle is driven over the "Proving Ground". Try a few simple events first - to give some data to the vehicle modellers. Then iterate on transducers and record the complete proving ground. Use the Somat proving ground surfaces. Possibly select another proving ground and also record. Time base digital recordings are required.
  8. Rig Test in Lab From the recorded vehicle data develop a simulation test for the full or partial sections of the vehicle. The test would allow a study in geater detail of vibration/etc. behavior of all or parts of the vehicle. It is possible that Brian Dabell at E.G.G. may be able to provide these tests to SAE F.D.& E. persons interested in the project.
  9. FEA model of Components: Select components that are of interest to durability analysts. Create FEA models. Use proving ground/or simulation load paths, and boundary conditions. Perform unit load analyses for all loads and elements.
  10. Component Redesign and Material Substitutions: Redesign the geometries of selected components and try some material subsitutions, such as PM steel, Cast Aluminum, Cast Magnesium. Predict fatigue life of original(?) new components.
  11. Shot Peening : Select a component that is a good candidate for durability improvements by shot peening (This could actually be done quite early in the project). Prepare a peening procedure for the component and predict the life improvement. Test it and see what happens.
  12. Lab Test new Components: Subject the components to simple and complex load histories in the test lab.
  13. Check Prediction with Component Test: Compare fatigue results between simulation and test.
  14. Re-measure Loads with new Components: Drive vehicle and record loads on the Somat Parking lot proving grounds. Observe similarities and differences between orinal and new component loads. Using strain gages, also observe "hot spot" fatigue areas responses to load inputs.
  15. Evaluate Results: of test and predictions. Point out weak areas. If possible work on improvements and try again.

Gleaned from above:
some potential student Projects:


(see also U.of I. (D.Socie) remarks in comments below).

Here are some tentative student type projects, should anyone be interested. They are not necessarily in critical path order:

  • Measure Vehicle geometry ..... Advisor: ?
  • Measure Inertial properties of components. ... Adv.: ?
  • Develop dynamics model ..... Advisor: Ric Mousseau
  • Redesign and Shot Peen a component. ... Adv.: ?
  • Measure Suspension Forces ..... Advisor: Dan Morrow
  • Measure first 3 resonace modes ... Adv.: ?
  • Develop simple suspension test....Adv. : ?
  • Photoelastic coating work ..... Adv. : ?
  • FEA analysis of component 1 ......Adv. : ?
  • FEA analysis of component 2 ......Adv. : ?
  • FEA analysis of component 3 ......Adv. : ?
  • Evaluate different types of Weld analyses on a welded component. ...Adv. : ?
  • Create a Web site to do display work and calculations and allow interactiver user changes to loads/materials components, and compute new fatigue durability.
  • Other ideas for such projects welcome.

Comments from Task Force Advisors: